When evaluating index funds, one has to look for the one that is best able to replicate the index and has a higher volume to execute the trades.
Index funds aren’t to outperform or underperform the underlying index. So all the Index ETFs will have the same performance over a period of time with almost no variation (or very slight variation) to the index.
Exchange Traded Funds or ETF, unlike mutual funds, require a demat account to trade. Know all about ETF’s here. Mutual funds try to beat the index whereas ETF’s replicate the index.
Available Nifty Index ETF
The important aspect of selecting a NIFTY Index ETF is not its performance because it will be very similar to Nifty. The important criteria are the average traded volume for the ETF. Higher volume for an ETF means it will have more buyers when one wants to be selling and vice versa.
50 companies are part of Nifty. So we will use Nifty 50 Index for ETF and have the following ETF’s.
Symbol at NSE | Average Traded Volume* | |
UTI-Nifty Exchange Traded Fund | UTINIFTETF | <500 |
Reliance ETF Nifty BeES | NIFTYBEES | 73,702 |
Invesco India Nifty ETF | IVZINNIFTY | <100 |
LIC MF ETF – CNX Nifty 50 | LICNETFN50 | <100 |
HDFC Nifty ETF | HDFCNIFETF | <500 |
Quantum Nifty ETF (G) | QNIFTY | <500 |
ICICI Prudential Nifty iWIN ETF | NIFTYIWIN | 17,174 |
ABSL Nifty ETF | BSLNIFTY | <500 |
IDFC NIFTY ETF | IDFNIFTYET | 2128 |
Kotak Nifty ETF | KOTAKNIFTY | 127,504 |
SBI – ETF Nifty 50 | SETFNIF50 | 2946 |
* Average volume data as per Yahoo finance as on 31st March 2018.
So one should always choose a Nifty Index ETF that has the maximum volume with minimum possible expense ratio.
The Top Nifty Index ETF
Based on our criteria for the high volume we have top 3 ETF as:
- Kotak Nifty ETF
- Reliance ETF Nifty BeES
- ICICI Prudential Nifty iWIN ETF.
The expense ratio for each of these funds is:
- Kotak Nifty ETF – 0.14%
- Reliance ETF Nifty BeES – 0.10%
- ICICI Prudential Nifty iWIN ETF – 0.05%
The Best Nifty Index ETF Fund
If one has to select the best based on expense ratio, it will be ICICI Prudential Nifty iWIN ETF.
If we select the mix of both where a better volume and moderate expense ratio, it has to be Reliance ETF Nifty BeES.
If you the ignore expense ratio, it has to be Kotak Nifty ETF.
Vishwakarma says
etf trading is future !! mostly i trade in large quantity in etf with my algo automated system.
Tejas Joshi says
What about SBI Nifty ETF? It has higher AUM and lowest ER. Also lowest tracking error.
Shabbir Bhimani says
Quite good as well.
Surya prakash chaturvedi says
Thanks .. I was searching this answer since long time,
Currently I am investing in NIFTY BEES .. I just wanted to make sure I am on right path or not.
Shabbir Bhimani says
Should be all good but still keep an eye on the average daily volume.
Dr. Jawahar Lal bansal says
Some Questions
1.Etf is better or index funds?
2.Return from ETF funds
3.There is liquidity problems in at the time of exit from ETF funds.
Shabbir Bhimani says
Answers
1. Check https://shabbir.in/etf-vs-mutual-fund/ There is no one solution that is better over other. One has to pick and choose based on the objective.
2. So what is your question? The ETF funds are more like stocks and less like funds in that respect.
3. If the fund is not very liquid then for both at the time of entry and exit .