Member Reviews of Make Money In Equity – The Free ebook by Shabbir Bhimani
I get quite a few reviews and feedback about my free ebook through email and one by S Sethuraman on Wed, Nov 11, 2009 was really worth mentioning and I quote
Hello Mr Shabbir Bhimani ,
Thank you for your follow up mail .
As you have mentioned I have unloaded your e book and it is really worth . But the point is that Iam practising the same approach since 2004 when I started active investment in MF’s after leaving my job . I read the fund house fact sheets and investment patterns and things like that for my decisions and do it myself . Generally I don’t have much belief on the fund managers since they can leave a fund house if another offers a better option and vice versa . But good fund houses like HDFC , FT , BSL , Fidelity etc are having their own benchmark and standards set and a good fund manager has only to perform within his territory . Yes there are proven and good fund managers and their track records are good . But there are others also who do insider trading ( you might be well aware ) and are greedy and make a mess of things . There were two three cases . Since I know most of the Indian Companies basics and things like that due to my last employment nature of service and travelled the whole of India and visited major companies , my investment decisions are more easier . I also read business papers and mags .
Iam also not a greedy investor and hopes for a decent returns with capital safety . During the last 5 years with investment in almost all fund houses good schemes I have an average income of about 25 % returns taxfree and all my capital intact with moderate growth as on date . Most of the funds I have taken more than my capital as dividents and still my capital as on date is grown moderately . I have only divi payout mode .
When I have gone thru your ebook , I found I was following most of it which was written . Similar approach I take in Share market, where Iam not a regular trader but like a disciplined long time investor with safe and steady approach and there again my result is as above .
Hope the above suffice your feedback query . Your ebook is good for people like me . Thanks for your efforts .
Thanks and Regards ,
S Sethuraman
Thanks for such a wonderful and detailed review.
So whats your feedback about the eBook? Share them in comments below.
Hi,
I just started reading this book and one immediate feedback is about a correction that is probably needed. The National Stock Exchange is not located at Delhi but is located at the Bandra Kurla Complex in Mumbai.
Sandeep, thanks for the feedback and I am in process of updating my ebook and will take your feedback into account.
A excellent book naratted in a very lucid language which makes things easy to understand
Thanks for the feedback Ravindra.
Sir,
Thanks for your ebook which is useful for all investors especially the beginners.Sir I wanted to know in the present market scenario,which are the best mutual funds to invest in through SIP route.Also please advice a mutual fund with less NAV price is better or a mutual fund with high NAV is better(if both the mutual funds are of similar category but different AMCS). More NAV less units purchased & less NAV more units purchased.What is opinion degarding this? One more query please suggest when to buy a mutual fund before the declaration of dividend or after the declaration of dividend?Your suggestions will be a great help to me & all investors like me.
Thanks & regards from,
Chandramohan Semwal.
It is the past performance and future outlook that matters and not the amount of units. I normally purchase before dividend for ELSS funds but not for all the funds.
hi,
I am unable to download ebook after confirming. i am getting page not found messge. can u pls send me the book to my mail id ashokarp@ymail.com.
Thanks.
ashok
Email sent and if you still have problems reply to the email and I will sent the ebook as attachment.
Hi
Yeah, this free E-book is very useful, honestly, mant people know the impact of fear &greed trade, but they do not realise when they have to realise, it is because unstability of their investments
shan
Sir
No issue pls tell me wht type of information , about my earning level, my acehivement or goal , pls reply.
Sir
I am fresher perosn in this field , but want to do invest 5000/- in SIP format , so pls guide me portfolio and accutare destiation for taking form or other requirement doc for start this processs.
Trilok, I am not sure if I can suggest you what is good for you without any knowledge about you. Also I like making people understand themselves how to invest instead of me doing the guiding work.
Hi Shabbir,
I would like to let you know that your compilation is definitely informative and helpful for any investor. Any newbie coming across your e-book would definitely be a much informed investor in many ways and would not be throwing away their hard earned money. The most important thing apart from these monetary matters what I feel about you is ‘You have a great help lending mind and being very much HUMAN in that matter’. I highly appreciate you for being too approachable and helpful. I didn’t have much time for an elaborate review, but couldn’t resist leaving a short reply as feedback. Thank you so much shabbir. Keep up your good work.Wishing you all the very best in all your endeavors. Will get back to you sooner than later. Cheers!
Naveen, thanks for the wonderful review and glad to see that it helps my readers.
you have some great ideas, going to check out your ebook. is that charting book free as well?
hey shabbir..
u got a grt stuff to share abt share market,,in India people still consider share trading a part of gambling,, dis is the perception dat resist dem to invest and participate in share market.. bt ur book may be a problem solver in dis regard,,,,,
3 words r sufficient for ur book… informative,,, easily understandable and must read,,,,
Akkin, Thanks for the wonderful feedback.
respected sir,
i read your e-book it is very innovative & helpful ,it enhance our knowledge about equity & stock market.i just want to say thanks to you
for this great work……….
Dear Shabbir
Your E-book is very informative and helpful. Same goes for the Blog.Thanks for sharing your knowledge with others. I look forward to reading your informative posts!!!
Regards,
Yameen
Yameen, thanks for the wonderful feedback
Hello,
I am myrina stein, associated with some financial communities. I am a regular reader of your site (http://shabbir.in) and trust me I really like reading your site.Your articles are informative and worth reading.
I am a financial writer and I would like to contribute an informative and relevant article for your site without charging you a penny.
I can give you a guest post and I assure you that it will be published only in your site.
Here are my few published articles, you can see,
http://www.houseoption.com/blog/foreclosures-portland/evade-foreclosure-by-lowering-your-mortgage-debt,
http://top10recent.com/choose-a-non-profit-debt-consolidation-company-to-solve-your-financial-crisis
http://blog.globalbx.com/2011/01/20/financing-a-business-loan-how-is-it-possible/
http://www.creditblossom.com/credit-repair-blog/credit-card-consolidation-the-fastest-way-to-defeat-the-debt-trap/
Please let me know your thoughts. Waiting for your positive reply. Reach me at, myrina.stein.888@gmail.com
Please feel free to get in touch with me regarding this anytime if you are interested.
God Bless,
Myrina Stein
Face book profile:
(http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001970691460)
Hi Myrina, I would love to have your views and articles provided they are targeted to Indian market and not finance in general.
Hello
I read your E-book and i really appreciate the efforts you put in to share the knowledge and ur efforts to spread the awareness.
I always look forward to any updates/articles/posts on your blog.
One thing i would say if you can put some efforts in redesigning/organizing the blog as well as E-book, like font,color, short paragraphs instead of long continuous details, that will be more interesting and help full.
Also it really helps to understand quickly if any concept or plan u have explained, is provided with a suitable illustration/example.
Nonetheless, superb blog , liked it very much .
Keep it up!
Nilesh
Nilesh, your input is taken and I will be updating the ebook soon.
book is almost good, but it does’t iclude any examples so that one can understand this marketing concept by only this book………
Chandan, For examples from the market you check out Chart Pattern book of mine.
Hi Shabbir,
Its trithful guide for beginner yes for me as well.
I got to know most of new things and directions where should follow.
Now i am going to make money through your suggestions.
But i would like to clarify one doubt that is,
Does the company performance always depends upon historic records,
Because it might happen the company will bounce back
So is it right to hold the stock of these kind of companies?
Regards
Amar
Hi Amar, Thanks for your feedback and yes history should help you to judge the future many times if not always.
thank you sir for providing me so useful information i hope in future you will remember me for sharing information thanks a lot
The e-book is very informative and useful.
I suggest it should include a chapter on “Calculation on incometax aspect”.
That ebook of yours quite impressive sir!.From what I have read so far, it really put me into the stage of being “confident” to join in stock market business. Those informative, dependable and tips would really be useful in such a way that people would really be interested about it.Thank you so much.
I really look forward to read other useful post from you. Its really interesting and thanks for sharing your knowledge with others.
I really look forward to read other useful post from you. Its really interesting and thanks for sharing your knowledge with others.
thanks a lot. thanks for sharing your tips with us. it was informative and helpful for me.
Sir,
I am very grateful to you for providing me the e-book “Make money in Equity”. This book is really an eye-opener for a new comer like me. Excellent work, keep it up. Thanks a lot once again.
Hi,
I receive an error when I try to download the guide.
Error: The file is damaged and could not be repaired. Please let me know how can this be fixed or send me a copy of it if anyone of you have it.
Do you have the latest Adobe PDF Reader. If no you should get one from here – http://get.adobe.com/reader/
Hi Shabbir,
Assumming that the markets dips in the next 1 year, isn’t “Orthodox SIP (where in u buy more units when the stocks dip) beneficial compared to “My Special SIP”?
Neel, SIP’s are better in falling markets but then you are all guessing and so when doing SIP you should concentrate more on investment needs and not on market because SIP nullify the extra ordinary ups and down.
Hi Sir,
Thanks for the e-book simple and effective.
I like to know more about banking funds,is its the correct time invest if yes then in which fund and for how long…
Dear Shabbir,
I feel that there is good future ahead for the Pharma stocks because of the bill that has been passed in US. There will be a lot of business outsorced in India.
Which do you think are some really goo dPharma stocks.
Nice and small. Basic investment explained in a simple and lucid way. Thanks Shabbir 🙂
Dear Shabbir,
I have really liked your e-book.
I appreciate the ways you have mentioned to select stocks.
I would like to know how does the trading quantity mentioned at NSE and BSE, or the offer qty. & bid qty. affect your decision for purchase or sell of stock. As per my understanding it only affects the short term pricing of the share. Am i right?
Also let me know: there are thousands of companies listed on NSE as well as BSE, how do you initially select the stocks for monitoring.
Ihave recently puchased ABAN offshore. What do u have to say about it.
Neha, Thanks for the feedback. Yes the exchange price difference is for a very short period and its mainly known as Arbitrage and if you search the blog about it you will see some real time examples as well.
For Initial list you can choose the 30 Nifty companies to start with or any subset of the list. http://shabbir.in/nifty-listed-companies/
ABAN is good stock but at what levels you buy is important.
Respected sir,
i like the basic investment tips given by you. i am finance student done M.com , PGDM ( FINANCE ) and also cleared NCFM amfi advisory , nsdl operations , derivatives dealers module and my keen intrest is to become a equity analyst so i need to learn about technical analysis as well as fndamental analysis so plz guide.
thanks for all your information ……..
Wow your book is very good. Thanks for your efforts.
It will be better if you write some more books of investment,share market and tax saving methods for salaried.
Keep rocking
Vijay, I will surely write more.
Hi Mr Shabbir Bhimani,
The book was great and very informative, I am 27, at this early stages of my life I started investing stock market in 2007. Soon after that market is hit by recesion in 2008 leaving me with 40% loss in shares. From your experience could you please write how to plan for the next immediate year, how to plan our portfolio. Why I am asking this question is these days market has become too much volatile. In your book it is written for all times, talking about normal market conditions. Any way can you provide how to manage portfolio for next year?
– Kena
Kena, I share recent information on this blog and you will updated about the weekly happenings every Monday and you can see the latest one about Factors you should consider when investing.
dear sir,
i read ur ebook. it was very informative. i have already gone through lot of investment books, still i could see new points from ur ebook. i appreciate ur interest in helping others eventhough u don’t have to. as i am learning abt stock picking, i was looking more about finding fair value of share with some example from ur book. u may kindly include the same if u feel that it is required. nevertheless, it is a great book to start.
with regards
dbr
Will do that soon. Thanks for the feedback
Dear Sir,
Thanks for the book it is really very informative and helpful.
I have a question that if i start elss sip from jan 2010 to jan 2012 what will the lock in period 3 years calculated date.The starting date or the closing date of my last sip installement.I shall be highly thankful for the information.
Thanks
Bhavnesh
last SIP and not first SIP.
Dear Sir,
First of all, i would like to thank you for providing the e-book “Make money in Equity”. This book is really an eye-opener for a new comer like me. This ebook has made me understand the nuances of stock market.
Sir, i have some doubts.
1. Am not uable to undestand the difference between Orthodox SIP, Non SIP and My Special SIP (Page 12)
2. In Orthodox SIP, investment amount will be 72000 for 12 months, but in Non-SIP, it is 62000 (12×5000 +2000). Not able to understand this.
3. And what is the advantage in My Special SIP way of investing?.
Thanks a ton again for the ebook.
Thanks,
Kalyan.
Kalyan,
Thanks for the feedback and here is the clarification of the terms.
1. I have suggested list of funds and in that list if you start SIP in all of them at the minimum possible level ( values in the table above ) you would be doing SIP using the orthodox way. If you do lump-sump investment this is non-sip. My Special SIP is out of 13 funds I invest in any one fund monthly choosing my own way. No monthly commitments and I invest when I have the fund and see the market dips.
2. Many funds have minimum amount for SIP and lump-sump one time investment and so the amount varies.
3. Advantage is you can invest in any particular fund which you think would do better than other like now you should select more midcap funds.
Thanks
Shabbir